Sag Harbor:

An Adventure For The Curious Diner

Sag Harbor, NY, is known for many things- as a pivotal port in the American Revolution, the epicenter of the whaling industry, a community for writers, and a significant port-of-call in Herman Melville’s epic Moby Dick. The modern adventurer will still find those elements in the modern village today, but like many great establishments it has evolved with the times and the demands of the population. Nowadays, Sag Harbor is notable for its beautiful nature preserves and beaches, it’s careful preservation of history, and it’s admirable array of truly delightful eateries.

Sag Harbor was the sight of America’s first customs house, predating even the one on Long Island, and is an apt symbol for the culinary adventures that await a hungry explorer. It’s a small slice of global food culture all packed into a gorgeous, quaint New England-style township. Don’t let the quaint whitewashed picket fences and weathered timbers fool you- this town knows it’s food, from elegant fireside dining to elbows-on-the-counter burger joints.

The American Hotel Website – – Trip Advisor
This flagship of fine dining is the epitome of refined taste and purportedly boasts a wine cellar equal to any fine eatery found in much more urban centers. Constantly busy (reservations are recommended!), but hosted by swift and kindly waitstaff, the food here promises and delivers on all the delights that can be found on the oceanside. Better yet, the entrees run the gamut from simple dishes that frame delightful fresh food to complex symphonies of flavor to challenge the most exacting foodie. The character is unparalleled with seating options ranging from the airy porch and atrium, to cozy fireside tables, to the luxuriously intimate Back Room.

Sen Restaurant Website – – Trip Advisor
Rough-hewn stone, exposed timbers, and warm lighting showcase the Japanese culinary expertise at Sen Restaurant. This romantic setting is known for both its epic quality sushi and its opportunities for celebrity spotting. Embracing both locally sourced and exotic fish of peak freshness, Sen’s delicate and exquisite flavors also stem from the highest quality sushi rice and a secret, in-house recipe for rice wine vinegar. Along with the welcoming atmosphere, this restaurant is known for its strict adherence to food allergy issues without losing deliciousness.

LT Burger Website – –Trip Advisor
From the opposite end of the spectrum is a simple yet surprising burger joint. LT’s carries the classic burger/fries/milkshake combo but with some delightful twists, like fried dill pickles, heirloom tomato salsa, and a spectrum of choices for French fries. Sporting an impressive breakfast menu and hand roasted beans from the Hampton Coffee Company, LT Burger’s versatility shows as an option for any time of day, and for any type of appetite. Solid meals, coffee breaks, and afternoon snacks all are done to perfection in this tidy white tiled diner.

Map/Chart of Sag Harbor

by LA DiNardi with Patty Mason